Dutch
Civil Code
Book 7 Particular agreements
Title 7.4 Lease agreement
Section 7.4.1 General provisions
Article 7:201 Definition of a 'lease agreement'
- 1. A lease
agreement is an agreement under which one of the parties, 'the lessor',
engages himself towards the other party, 'the lessee', to grant him the
use of an immovable or movable thing or of a part of such thing, opposite
to which the lessee engages himself to perform a counter performance.
- 2. A lease
agreement may also be related to the use of valuable rights. In that event
the provisions of this Section (Section 7.4.1) and of Sections 7.4.2 up
to and including 7.4.4 are applicable to the lease agreement as far as
the scope of these provisions does not oppose to such an application in
view of the nature of the valuable right.
- 3. A farm lease
agreement is not regarded as a lease agreement.
Article 7:202 Entitlement to the fruits (benefits)
of the leased thing
If the lessee is entitled to the fruits (benefits) of the leased property,
then this right is regarded as a right to enjoy that property as meant
in Article 5:17 of the Civil Code. The lessee obtains this right from
the commencement date of the lease, on the understanding that civil fruits
(civil benefits) shall be calculated from day up to day.
Section 7.4.2 Obligations of the
lessor
Article 7:203 Placing the leased out property at the
disposal of the lessee
The lessor is obliged to place the leased out property at the disposal
of the lessee and to leave it at his disposal insofar this is necessary
to comply with the agreed enjoyment (right of use).
Article 7:204 Defects in the leased property
- 1. With regard
to defects in the leased property, the lessor has the obligations as described
in this Section (Section 7.4.2).
- 2. A defect
is a quality or characteristic of the leased property or another circumstance
not attributable to the lessee, as a result of which the leased property
does not provide the lessee the enjoyment which a lessee, at the moment
on which the lease agreement was entered into, could have expected to
get of a well maintained property of the kind as to which the lease agreement
relates.
- 3. An actual
disturbance in the agreed enjoyment by a third person who does not claim
to have a right in the leased property as meant in Article 7:211, is no
defect in the meaning of paragraph 2; neither a defect is the claim of
a third person to the leased property itself, but without actually causing
a disturbance in the agreed enjoyment.
Article 7:205 The rights (actions) and legal remedies of Book 6 of
the Civil Code
The lessee is entitled to the rights (actions) that result from this Section (Section
7.4.2) without prejudice to all other rights (actions) and legal remedies available
to him pursuant to law.
Article 7:206 Remedy of defects
- 1. If the lessee desires so, the lessor
must remedy a defect, unless this is impossible or it would require expenditures
which in the given circumstances reasonably cannot be expected to be made
by the lessor.
- 2. This obligation does not apply to minor
defects which the lessee has to repair himself pursuant to Article 7:217,
nor to defects for which the lessee is responsible (liable) towards the
lessor.
- 3. Where the lessor is in default of remedying
a defect, the lessee may perform the remedy himself; as far as the remedy
costs are reasonable, they may be recovered from the lessor, if required
by withholding them from the rent. It is not possible to derogate to the
disadvantage of the lessee from this provision.
Article 7:207 Reduction of the rent
- 1. In the event that the enjoyment of the
lease has been diminished due to a defect, the lessee may claim a proportional
reduction of the rent as from the day on which he has properly notified
the lessor of the defect or on which the defect was sufficiently known
to the lessor in order to take measures, up until the day that the defect
is remedied.
- 2. The lessee is not entitled to a reduction
of the rent to the point of minor defects that he has to repair himself
pursuant to Article 7:217, nor of defects for which he is responsible
(liable) towards the lessor.
Article 7:208 Damages
Without prejudice to the rights and legal remedies of the lessee in the
event of a non-performance of the obligation meant in Article 7:206, the
lessor is obliged to compensate the damage caused by the defect, if the
defect has arisen after the conclusion of the lease agreement and is attributable
to him, as well as if the defect already existed at the conclusion of
the lease agreement and the lessor was aware or ought to have been aware
of its existence or the lessor had made clear, at that time, that the
leased property did not have this defect.
Article 7:209 Mandatory law
It is not possible to derogate to the disadvantage of the lessee from
Articles 7:206, paragraph 1 and 2, 7:207 and 7:208 as far as it concerns
defects of which the lessor was aware or ought to have been aware at the
conclusion of the lease agreement.
Article 7:210 No agreed enjoyment left
- 1. If a defect makes it entirely impossible
to enjoy the leased property in conformity with the lease agreement, but
from Article 7:206 follows that the lessor is not obliged to remedy this
defect, then both, the lessee and the lessor, may rescind the lease agreement
on the basis of Article 6:267 of the Civil Code.
- 2. The damage caused by the fact that the
lease agreement has ended in consequence of paragraph 1, may be recovered
by virtue of a debt-claim for damages caused by a defect.
Article 7:211 Rights of action (legal claims) of third
persons against the lessee
- 1. When a third person has filed a legal
claim (right of action) against the lessee with the objective to sell
off the leased property by foreclosure or to obtain a right or title in
the leased property with which that property should not have been burdened
according to the lease agreement, then the lessor is obliged, as soon
as the lessee has notified him of this legal claim (right of action),
to enter the legal proceedings in order to defend the interests of the
lessee.
- 2. The lessor must compensate the lessee
for all costs incurred with regard to this legal claim (right of action),
though, if the notification was not given immediately, only the costs
that have arisen after that notification have to be compensated.
- 3. When the main lessor has filed a legal
claim (right of action) against a sublessee in relation to the subleased
property, the previous paragraphs apply accordingly to the sublessor.
For the purpose of Article 212 of the Code of Civil Procedure, this legal
claim (right of action) against the sublessee is equated with a legal
claim (right of action) with the objective to sell off a debtor's property
by foreclosure.
Section 7.4.3 The obligations of
the lessee
Article 7:212 Counter performance
The lessee is obliged to perform a counter performance in the agreed way
and at the agreed times.
Article 7:213 Prudent lessee
The lessee is obliged to behave himself with regard to the use of the
leased property as a prudent lessee.
Article 7:214 Use in conformity with the intended
purpose
The lessee is only entitled to use the leased property as agreed upon
and, when parties have not made an agreement on this, to use it in conformity
with the purpose for which it is intended by its nature.
Article 7:215 Changes to the leased property
- 1. The lessee is not entitled to change,
in full or in part, the functional arrangement or shape of the leased
property without a written consent of the lessor, unless it concerns changes
and additives which at the end of the lease agreement can be made undone
and removed without noteworthy costs.
- 2. Where the lease agreement concerns the
use of a residential space and the planned changes shall not adversely
affect the possibilities to lease out the property nor will they decrease
its value, the lessor must give his consent within eight weeks.
- 3. If the lessor does not give his consent,
then the lessee may claim in court to get authorised to carry out the
planned changes himself. If the lessor is not also the owner, usufructuary
or long leaseholder of the leased property, then the lessor ensures that
the owner, usufructuary or long leaseholder is called in time to the legal
proceedings as well. If the leased property is encumbered with a mortgage,
then this obligation also exists towards the mortgagee.
- 4. The court
shall in any case award the legal claim if the lessor should have given
his consent pursuant to paragraph 2. In other situations the court shall
only award the legal claim if the changes are necessary for an efficient
use by the lessee of the leased property or they improve the enjoyment
that the lessee may have of the leased property, always provided that
the lessor cannot bring forward compelling objections against these changes.
- 5. The court
may subject its authorisation to certain conditions or duties; upon the
request of the lessor, it may also raise the rent if the changes give
rise to that.
- 6. It is not
possible to derogate to the disadvantage of the lessee from the previous
paragraphs, unless it concerns the outside of the leased residential space.
Article 7:216 Right of removal and right of compensation
- 1. Up until the eviction the lessee is entitled
to undo and remove the changes and additives he has introduced, provided
that the leased property is brought back to a condition which at the end
of the lease period reasonably can be regarded as being in conformity
with its original state.
- 2. Before evicting the leased property the
lessee does not need to undo or remove rightfully introduced changes or
additives, notwithstanding the competence of the court to impose such
a duty upon him on the basis of Article 7:215, paragraph 5.
- 3. With regard to rightfully introduced
changes and additives that are not undone or removed after the lease period
has ended, the lessee may claim a compensation from the lessor to the
extend that such a compensation is claimable under Article 6:212 of the
Civil Code [unjustified enrichment].
Article 7:217 Minor repairs
The lessee must, at his own expense, repair minor defects, unless it has
become necessary to make these repairs because the lessor has failed to
comply with his duty to remedy defects for which he is responsible (liable)
[see Artice 7:240].
Article 7:218 Presumption of proof with regard to
the liability of the lessee
- 1. The lessee is responsible (liable) for
the damage caused to the leased property by a failure to comply with an
obligation imposed on him by the lease agreement as far as this failure
is attributable to him.
- 2. All damage is presumed to have been caused
by an attributable failure as referred to in paragraph 1, except for damage
caused by fire and, in case of a lease of constructed immovable property
or a part thereof, damage at the outside of the leased property.
- 3. Without prejudice to Article 7:224, paragraph
2, the lessee is presumed to have received the leased property in an undamaged
condition.
Article 7:219 Liability of the lessee for behaviour
of third persons
In the same way as the lessee is responsibly (liable) towards the lessor
for his own behaviour, he is responsible (liable) towards him for the
behaviour of those who under his approval use the leased property or find
themselves on (in) it.
Article 7:220 Urgent works and renovations
- 1. If it is necessary that during the lease
period urgent works are carried out to the leased property or if the lessor
must tolerate that during the lease period others use his property pursuant
to Article 5:56 of the Civil Code to carry out such works on behalf of
the adjoining premises, then the lessee must give opportunity to perform
these works, without prejudice to his right to claim a reduction of the
rent, to rescind the lease agreement and to claim a compensation for damages
[always if this would be possible on these grounds according to the requirements
set to this end by law].
- 2. Paragraph 1 shall apply accordingly when
the lessor, with continuation of the lease, wants to proceed to a renovation
of the constructed immovable thing to which the lease agreement relates,
and he makes a proposal to this end that, in view of his own interests
and of the interests of the lessee and possible sublessees, is reasonable.
Such a proposal has to be made in writing. By a renovation is understood
the demolition of the existing immovable thing followed by the construction
of a newly built immovable thing, or a partial renewal of the existing
immovable thing by changing it or by adding works or constructions to
it.
- 3. If the renovation concerns ten or more
dwelling houses or buildings used for retail purposes, which together
form an architectural unity, then the proposal referred to in paragraph
2 is presumed to be reasonable when 70% or more of the lessees have agreed
to it. A lessee who has not agreed with the proposal may, within eight
weeks after the lessor has given notice in writing to him that 70% or
more of the lessees have agreed to the proposal, ask the court to decide
whether the proposal is reasonable or not.
- 4. The previous
paragraphs do not deprive the lessor from his right to terminate the lease
agreement on the ground that he needs the immovable thing urgently to
make necessary renovations, as far as this can be brought under the legal
grounds for termination which apply pursuant to law to a constructed immovable
thing as to which the lease agreement relates.
- 5. If relocation (moving away) is necessary
in connection with the proposed renovation, referred to in paragraph 2,
third sentence, of a residential space as meant in Article 7:233, then
the lessor must contribute in the costs which the lessee has to make with
regard to the relocation (moving expenses).
- 6. The minimum contribution in the costs
of relocation (moving expenses) and settling-in costs, to be made by lessees
of separate dwellings as referred to in Article 7:234 and mobile homes
and mobile home stands as referred to in Articles 7:235 and 7:236, will
be determined by means of a Ministerial Decree of the Minister for Housing,
Communities and Integration and will be amended each year, before 1 March,
as far as the consumer price index (CPI) gives reason to do so. The amount
mentioned in the first sentence shall be rounded off upwards or downwards
to whole euros.
- 7. Contributions in or compensations for
moving expenses and settling-in costs, provided by the municipality to
the lessee, may be deducted from the contribution that the lessor has
to pay pursuant to paragraph 6.
Article 7:221 Sublease
The lessee is entitled to grant a right of use of the leased property
or of a part thereof to a third party, unless he had to assume that the
lessor has reasonable objections against granting such a right of use
to this third person.
Article 7:222 Duty to inform the lessor of defects
If the lessee has discovered defects in the leased property or if third
persons disturb him in his enjoyment of the leased property or if they
claim to have rights in the leased property themselves, then the lessee
must notify the lessor immediately thereof, and failing in doing so, he
has to compensate the damage that the lessor suffers due to this negligence.
Article 7:223 Duty to allow potential lessees or buyers
to make a visit
When the lessor wants to lease out the leased property after the current
lease agreement has ended or when he wants to sell the leased property
to someone else, the lessee of that immovable property or of a part thereof,
has to tolerate that the usual signs and posters are placed on or attached
to the immovable property and he has to give opportunity to potential
lessees or buyers to visit the property and to look around.
Article 7:224 Duty to return the leased property at
the end of the lease
- 1. At the end of the lease the lessor is
obliged to place the leased property at the disposal of the lessor.
- 2. When the lessee and lessor have made
a description of the condition of the leased property, the lessee has
to return the leased property in the same condition as in which it was
accepted according to that description, with exception of rightfully added
changes and additives and of what was destroyed or damaged by aging or
normal use. If no description of the condition of the leased property
was made, the lessee is presumed to have received the leased property
in the condition as it is at the end of the lease, notwithstanding the
right of the lessor to prove the contrary.
Article 7:225 No eviction in good time
Where the lessee unlawfully keeps hold of the leased property after the
lease has ended, the lessor may, over the period that he misses the leased
property, claim damages equal to the rent, without prejudice to his right
to claim a higher compensation if this rent is not sufficient to cover
all the damage suffered.
Section 7.4.4 Passage of the lease
agreement when the leased property is transferred and the ending of the
lease
Article 7:226 Passage of the lease at a transfer of
the leased property
- 1. A transfer by the lessor of the property
to which the lease agreement is related or the establishment or transfer
by the lessor of an independent usufruct, long leasehold or right of superficies
on the property to which the lease agreement is related, makes that the
rights and obligations of the lessor derived from the lease agreement,
that will become due and demandable as of this moment, pass to the acquiring
party.
- 2. A transfer of the leased property by
a creditor of the lessor is equated with a transfer by the lessor himself.
- 3. The acquiring party is only bound by
those contractual provisions of the lease agreement that directly relate
to the use of the leased property as granted by the lessor in exchange
of the counter performance to be performed by the lessee.
- 4. Where the lease agreements relates to
a constructed immovable thing or a part thereof or to a mobile home in
the sense of Article 7:235 or a mobile home stand in the sense of Article
7:236, it is not possible to derogate from the previous paragraphs.
Article 7:227 Lease has priority over a later established
real property right
In case of the establishment or transfer of a limited real property right
on the leased property that is not covered by Article 7:226, paragraph
1, the limited proprietor is towards the lessee obliged to refrain himself
from exercising his right as far as this would lead to an interference
with the use which the lessee may make of the encumbered property [this
applies also to a later vested mortgage on the leased property].
Article 7:228 End of the lease due to the expiry of
the lease period or a termination
- 1. A lease agreement concluded for a fixed
term ends on the expiry of that term, without a termination being necessary.
- 2. A lease agreement concluded or extended
for an indefinite term ends by termination. When the lease agreement relates
to immovable property, not being a residential space or a retail building,
then the day on which the termination will take effect must be a day on
which the rent has to be paid according to the lease agreement, taking
into account a term of notice of at least one month.
Article 7:229 Consequences of the death of one of
the parties
- 1. The death of the lessee or the lessor
does not end the lease agreement.
- 2. When the estate (inheritance) of the
deceased lessee is apportioned in accordance with Article 4:13 of the
Civil Code [intestate succession] and the heirs of the lessee are not
entitled to grant a right of use of the leased property to a third person,
then the lease agreement may be terminated during six months after the
death of the lessee by his heirs or his spouse or his registered partner,
taking into account a term of notice of at least one month.
- 3. If the deceased lessee leaves behind
two or more heirs, then the lessor is obliged to cooperate in the apportionment
by the joint heirs of the rights and obligations out of the lease agreement
to one or more of the heirs, unless the lessor has reasonable objections
against one or more of the selected heirs. The first sentence does not
apply if the estate (inheritance) of the deceased lessee is apportioned
pursuant to Article 4:13 of the Civil Code [intestate succession].
Article 7:230 Actual continuation of the lease after
it has ended
If the lessee, after the agreed lease period has expired, keeps making
use of the leased property with permission of the lessor, then as a result,
unless there turns out to be another intention, the lease agreement will
be continued for an indefinite period of time, irrespective of the time
for which it was entered into initially.
Article 7:230a Eviction at the end of the lease of
constructed immovable property not being a residential space or a retail
building
- 1. Where the lease agreement relates to
constructed immovable property not being a residential space or a retail
building, or to a part of such immovable property, the lessee may, at
the end of the lease period, request the court to extend the period within
which the eviction of the leased property must be completed. The application
of the lessee must be lodged within two months after the day on which
the leased property has to be evicted according to a written notice of
eviction of the lessor.
- 2. Paragraph 1 is not applicable when the
lessee has terminated the lease agreement himself, when he explicitly
has given his consent to end the lease agreement or when he has been ordered
by the court to evict the leased property because he as failed to comply
with his obligations.
- 3. The lessor cannot demand that the lessee
proceeds to an eviction before the end of the period referred to in paragraph
1. The lodging of an application by the lessee suspends his duty to proceed
to an eviction of the leased property until the court has decided on his
request by a final and binding judicial decision.
- 4. The court may only award the request
of the lessee if the interests of the lessee and of the sublessee to whom
the leased property or a part thereof has been subleased rightfully, will
be more seriously damaged by the eviction than the interests of the lessee
will be damaged by a continuation of the use of the leased property by
the lessee. The request is nevertheless rejected if the lessor makes plausible
that it cannot be expected of him that the lessee preserves his right
to use the leased property or a part thereof because of improper use of
the leased property, serious nuisance inflicted upon other users of the
property or upon the lessor or because of a default of payment.
- 5. An extension
of the period meant in paragraph 1 may be granted for a maximum period
of one year after the lease agreement has ended. Upon the request of the
lessee, this period may be extended two more times, each time for a maximum
period of one year. The application for an extension of the period must
be lodged at the latest one month before the expiration of the running
period. Paragraph 3, second sentence, and paragraph 4, apply accordingly.
- 6. Where parties do not agree on the sum
which the lessee has to pay for the use of the leased property or a part
thereof during the extended period meant in the present Article, the court
shall set this sum to an amount that, in view of the local rent sums,
is reasonable. Upon the request of one of the parties, the court may to
this point provide a provisional ruling. Other than that, the rights and
obligations out of the lease agreement remain effective between the parties
during the extended period meant in the present Article.
- 7. Where the
court rejects the request of the lessee, it will determine the moment
on which the leased property has to be evicted. Such a court order is
considered to be a judgment to evict the leased property on the designated
moment.
- 8. No appeal to a higher court is open against
a judicial decision as meant in the present Article.
- 9. It is not possible to derogate to the
disadvantage of the lessee from the provisions of the present Article.
Article 7:231 Rescission of the lease agreement by
the court
- 1. The rescission of a lease agreement relating
to constructed immovable property or to a mobile home in the sense of
Article 7:235 or a mobile home stand in the sense of Article 7:236, on
the ground that the lessee has failed to comply with his obligations,
can only take place by judicial decision, except in the situation meant
in Article 7:210, paragraph 2, of the Civil Code.
- 2. The lessor may rescind such a lease agreement
himself by virtue of Article 6:267 of the Civil Code on the ground that
certain behaviour in the leased property has lead to a disturbance of
public order and, as a result, the leased property has been shut down
by public authorities under Article 174a of the Municipality Act or under
a Municipal Ordinance as meant in Article 174 of that Act or on the ground
that certain behaviour in the leased property has been in violation of
Article 2 or 3 of the Opium Act and, as a result, the concerned building
has been shut down by public authorities under Article 13b of that Act
or such a building has been shut down by public authorities under Article
17 of the Housing Act.
- 3. It is not possible to derogate to the
disadvantage of the lessee from paragraph 1.
Section 7.4.5 Lease of residential
spaces
Subsection 7.4.5.1 General provisions
Article 7:232 Applicability of statutory provisions
and exceptions
- 1. This Section (Section 7.4.5) only applies
to the lease of residential spaces.
- 2. This Section (Section 7.4.5) does not
apply to lease agreements concerning the use of residential spaces which
use by its nature is of short duration.
- 3. During the first nine months after the
lease has taken effect, Articles 7:206, paragraph 3, 7:270, 7:271, paragraph
4, 7:272, 7:273, 7:274, 7:275, 7:276, 7:277 and 7:281 do not apply to
the lease of a residential space which is not a separate dwelling of its
own, but a part of a dwelling in which the lessor has his main residence,
provided that in the past no residential spaces in this dwelling have
been leased out already to this lessee.
- 4. Articles 7:206, paragraph 3, 7:269, paragraph
1 and 2, 7:270, 7:271 up to and including 7:277, 7:278, paragraph 1 and
2, and 7:281 do not apply to the lease of a residential space in a building
which belongs to the municipality and which, at the moment of the conclusion
of the lease agreement, is already intended for demolition.
Article 7:233 'Residential space'
By a 'residential space' is understood a constructed immovable thing as
far as it has been leased out as a separate or dependent dwelling, or
a mobile home or a mobile home stand, as well as their immovable accessories.
Article 7:234 'Separate dwelling'
By a 'separate dwelling' is understood a residential space that has its
own access and that can be used by its occupant as a residence without
having to revert to basic facilities outside the dwelling.
Article 7:235 'Mobile home'
By a 'mobile home' is understood a construction, intended to be used for
occupation, that has been placed on a mobile home stand and that can be
removed in full or in part, and for which a surroundings
permit has been issued for a construction operation as meant in Article 2.1, paragraph 1, under point (a), of the Act on General Provisions for Surroundings Law.
Article 7:236 'Mobile home stand'
By a 'mobile home stand' is understood a plot of land, intended to place
a mobile home on, where facilities are available that can be connected
to the pipeline network for gas, water and electricity distribution of
public or other institutions or of municipalities.
Article 7:237 'Lease price', rent' and 'service charges'
- 1. In this Section (Section 7.4.5) by 'lease
price' is understood all obligations incumbent upon the lessee towards
the lessor by virtue of the lease agreement.
- 2. By 'rent' is understood the price which
is solely chargeable for the use and enjoyment of the residential space.
- 3. By 'service charges' is understood the
compensation chargeable for provided goods and services in connection
with the occupation of the residential space. By Order in Council goods
and services may be pointed out for which the compensation must be regarded
as service charges.
Article 7:238 'Rent committee'
By 'rent committee' is understood the rent committee meant in Article
3a of the Implementation Act Residential Rents.
Article 7:239 'Minister'
By 'Minister' is understood the Minister of Public Housing, Spatial Planning
and the Environment.
Article 7:240 Minor repairs of residential spaces
By Order in Council [Decree on Minor
Repairs] defects may be pointed out that have to be regarded as minor
defects which under Article 7:217 must be repaired by the lessee himself
and for his own account. It is not possible to derogate to the disadvantage
of the lessee from provisions that have been enacted by virtue of the
present Article.
Article 7:241 Order in Council for defects
By or pursuant to an Order in Council it will be determined which imperfections
in any event shall be regarded as defects. It is not possible to derogate
to the disadvantage of the lessee from provisions that have been enacted
by virtue of the present Article.
Article 7:242 Semi-mandatory law for the lease of
residential spaces
- 1. Except by means of a Standard Regulation
as meant in Article 6:214 of the Civil Code*), it is
not possible to derogate to the disadvantage of the lessee from the provisions
of Articles 7:204, 7:206, paragraph 1 and 2, 7:207, 7:208 and 7:217, unless
it concerns repairs of changes and additives to the leased property that
were added by the lessee or defects in such changes and additives.
- 2. It is not possible to derogate to the
disadvantage of the lessee from the provisions of Articles 7:216, paragraph
3, 7:224, paragraph 2, and 7:230.
*) Up until now no such Standard
Regulation has been issued.
Article 7:243 Demanding energy saving measures
- 1. If a residential space in a constructed
immovable property needs energy saving improvements as meant in paragraph
2, then the court may, upon the request of the lessee, order that the
lessor must place such improvements at his own expense, provided that
the lessee has declared that he is prepared to pay a reasonable rent increase
in proportion to these costs. It is not possible to derogate to the disadvantage
of the lessee from this provision.
- 2. The improvements meant in paragraph 1
are:
a. thermal insulation of external partition
constructions;
b. thermal insulation of the construction which
forms the partition with the crawl way;
c. a heater, placed on behalf of a heating
system, with an induction efficiency of at least 80%, if the existing
heater is at least ten years old.
Article 7:244 Subleasing of a residential space
Contrary to Article 7:221, the lessee of a residential space is not entitled
to grant a right of use of the leased property or of a part thereof to
a third party. The lessee of a separate dwelling who has his main residence
in that dwelling is, however, entitled to grant a right of use of the
leased property or of a part thereof to a third party.
Article 7:245 Implementation Act on Housing Rent
The Implementation Act on Housing Rent shall give more provisions for
rents and other compensations.
Subsection 7.4.5.2 Rent and other compensations
§ 1. Rent
Article 7:246 Freedom of contract
The rent which parties have agreed upon shall apply to the lease of residential
spaces, insofar nothing else results from this Subsection (Subsection
7.4.5.2).
Article 7:247 Liberalized residential spaces
With exception of Articles 7:249, 7:251, 7:259, 7:261, paragraph 1, and
7:264, the following Articles of this Subsection (Subsection 7.4.5.2)
do not apply to a lease agreement related to a separate residential space
with respect to which at the start of its occupation by the current lessee
a rent applied or applies which, if necessary recalculated to an amount
per year, is higher than the amount that has been determined under Article
3 paragraph 2 of the Implementation Act on Housing Rent, provided also
that:
a. this agreement was concluded on or after
1 July 1994, or;
b. this agreement is related to a dwelling
which was built on or after 1 July 1989.
Article 7:248 Indexation clause
- 1. The rent may be raised either on the
basis of a contractual provision in the lease agreement which provides
for such a rent increase or, if such a contractual provision is not stipulated
or not effective, in the way provided for in Articles 7:252, 7:252a and 7:253.
Articles 7:252 and 7:253 shall not apply during the effective existence
of such a contractual provision. If such a contractual provision is no
longer effective, the two aforementioned Articles shall become applicable
as of twelve months after the moment on which this contractual provision
has been made use of most recently.
- 2. Should the application of a contractual
provision as meant in paragraph 1 lead to an increase of the rent for
a higher percentage than the maximum rent increase percentage set by the
Minister as meant in Article 10 paragraph 2 of the Implementation Act
on Housing Rent, then this contractual provision is null and void insofar
it would lead to this higher percentage. In that event the rent is considered
to have been raised with the maximum rent increase percentage as set by
the Minister.
Article 7:249 Request of the lessee addressed to the
rent committee
Where the lessee has entered into a lease agreement with regard to a specific
residential space for the first time, he may, up to six months after the
moment on which this lease has become effective, request the rent committee
to determine whether the agreed rent is reasonable.
Article 7:250 Change of the rent upon a request of
the lessor or lessee
- 1. The rent may be raised upon the request
of the lessor in the way prescribed in Articles 7:252, 7:252a and 7:253:
a. during the first period of twelve months
after the day on which the lease has become effective: only once,
b. and furthermore each time at the end of
each other succeeding period of twelve months as from the moment on which
the rent increase as meant under point (a) has become effective or, when
such a rent increase has not occurred, as from the day the lease itself
has become effective.
- 2. An increase of the rent on the basis
of paragraph 1 is not possible as long as the lessee and lessor have not
come to an agreement over the defects in the residential space that have
been identified under the application of Article 12 and 16 of the Implementation
Act on Housing rent.
- 3. Contrary to paragraph 1, the rent may
be raised at the end of a period which is so much shorter than twelve
months as the preceding period has been longer than twelve months from
the day on which the rent was raised for that period.
- 4. Upon the request of the lessee, the rent
may be reduced in the way prescribed in Articles 7:252, 7:252b and 7:254.
Article 7:251 Rent increase at the most once a year
Any contractual provision in the lease agreement which might have the
effect that the rent may be increased more than once during a period of
twelve months is null and void, unless it concerns a situation as meant
in Article 7:255.
Article 7:252 Written proposition to change the rent
- 1. A proposal to change the rent must be
made in writing at least two months before the proposed day as of which
the change shall take effect.
- 2. The proposal meant in paragraph 1 must
at least mention:
a. the rent before it is changed;
b. the percentage or the amount of the change
of the rent;
c. the proposed new rent;
d. the proposed day as of which the proposed
new rent shall become effective;
e. the way how and the period within which
the lessee, if he wants to object against the proposal, must show his
objections as well as the legal effects which will enter pursuant to this
Subsection (Subsection 7.4.5.2) if he does not make his objections known.
- 3. In making a proposal to reduce the rent
an assessment of the quality of the residential space as meant in Article
10, paragraph 1, of the Implementation Act on Housing Rent must be submitted.
- 4. If an agreement to change the rent has
come about as a result of a proposal made to this end, which proposal,
however, was not in line with the requirements of paragraph 1, paragraph
2 under point (b), (d) or (e), or paragraph 3, then the previously applying
rent remains chargeable, unless the person to whom the proposal was made
appears not to have been harmed by the failure to comply with one or more
of these requirements.
Article 7:252a Increase of rent related to the income
of the lessee
- 1. A lessor may, in respect of a residential
space which forms an separate dwelling, make a proposal as referred to
in Article 7:252, with the purpose to increase the rent on the ground
that the household income in the reference year:
a. is higher than the amount mentioned in Article
10, paragraph 2, first sentence, of the Implementation Act Rental Price
Residential Spaces, but less than or equal to the amount mentioned under
(b) of that paragraph, or;
b. exceeds the amount mentioned in Article
10, paragraph 2, first sentence, under (b), of that Act.
- 2. In the present Article the following words
shall mean:
a. ‘basic registration income’:
basic registration income as provided in Chapter IVA of the General Act
on State Taxes;
b. ‘household income’: the total
amount of the income data, referred to in Article 21, under (e) of the
General Act on State Taxes, of the lessee and other occupants of a residential
space, on the understanding that where an other occupant has not reached
the age of 23 years on 1 January of the year in which the proposed date
of the start of the proposed rent finds itself, the amount of the income
data shall be taken into account only insofar as it is more than the result
of 108% of twelve times the monthly amount referred to in Article 8, paragraph
1, under (a) a of the Minimum Wage and Minimum Holiday Allowance Act,
as in force on 1 January of the reference year;
c. ‘inspector’: an officer of the
national tax authority who is designated as such by regulation of the
Minister of Finance;
d. ‘reference year’: the second
calendar year preceding the calendar year in which the proposed date of
the start of the proposed rent finds itself.
- 3. When a proposal as meant in paragraph
1 has been made, a declaration issued by the inspector to the lessor upon
the latter’s request, is added to the proposal.
- 4. The declaration referred to in paragraph
3 indicates whether it is to be expected, at the place of the residential
space designated by the lessor on the basis of data from the basic registration
income at the moment of handling the request of the lessor by the inspector,
that the household income in the reference year of the person or persons
who live there according to the registration of the tax authorities, is
less than or equal to the amount mentioned first in Article 10, paragraph
2, first sentence, under (a), of the Implementation Act Rental Price Residential
Spaces, or is higher than that amount but less than or equal to the last
mentioned amount in the aforementioned sentence under (a), or is higher
than that amount. Furthermore, the declaration mentions, if the household
income is higher than the amount mentioned first in Article 10, paragraph
2, first sentence, under (a), of the Implementation Act Rental Price Residential
Spaces, the number of persons on which the household income is based.
When there are no income data available in the basic registration income,
the declaration shall mention this. Further rules may be set by regulation
of the Minister of Finance for the implementation of the present paragraph
and on the ability to make a request, the request itself, the issuance
of the declaration, and as regards the lessor.
- 5. If an agreement on changing the rental
price has come about on account of a proposal for that purpose that does
not meet the requirements of paragraph 3, then the increase of the rental
price on the basis of a proposal as meant in paragraph 1 is not possible,
unless it appears that the lessee has not been harmed by the omission.
- 6. An agreement on changing the rental price:
a. resulting from a proposal referred to in
paragraph 1, opening words and under (a) and (b), does not come about
(has no effect) if the lessee can show that he or another member of the
household is part of a group to be determined by regulation of the Minister;
b. resulting from a proposal referred to in
paragraph 1, opening words and under (a), does not come about (has no
effect) if the lessee can show that the household income in the calendar
year following the reference year is equal to or less than the amount
mentioned first in Article 10, paragraph 2, first sentence, under (a),
of the Implementation Act Rental Price Residential Spaces, and;
c. resulting from a proposal referred to in
paragraph 1, opening words and under (b), does not come about (has no
effect) if the lessee can show that the household income in the calendar
year following the reference year is equal to or less than the amount
mentioned in that sentence under (b). This proposal is considered to be
a proposal referred to in paragraph 1, opening words and under (a), unless
the lessee can show as well that the household income in the calendar
year following the reference year is equal to or less than the amount
mentioned first in that sentence under (a).
Article 7:252b Decrease of rent related to a decrease in income of the
lessee
- 1. Without prejudice to Article 7:252a, paragraph
6, a lessee may in regard of a residential space which forms a separate
dwelling and in regard of which an increase of the rental price has taken
place on the basis of Article 7:252a, paragraph 1, submit a proposal referred
to in Article 7:252, with the purpose to decrease the rental price on
the ground that the household income referred to in Article 7:252a, paragraph
2, under (b), where the aforementioned increase was based on, has lessened
and with that:
a. has become equal to or less than the amount
mentioned in Article 14, paragraph 1, of the Housing Allowance Act;
b. has become equal to or less than the amount
mentioned first in Article 10, paragraph 2, first sentence, under (a),
of the Implementation Act Rental Price Residential Spaces, or
c. has become more than the amount referred
to under (b) but equal to or less than the amount mentioned in Article
10, paragraph 2, first sentence, under (b), of the Implementation Act
Rental Price Residential Spaces.
- 2. If a proposal referred to in paragraph
1 has been made, the lessee shall provide the relevant data related to
the household income. Which data the lessee shall have to provide in such
case, shall be determined by a regulation of the Minister.
- 3. If an agreement on changing the rental
price has come about on account of a proposal to that effect, which does
not meet the requirements of paragraph 2 , then a decrease of the rental
price on the basis of a proposal referred to in paragraph 1, is not possible,
unless it appears that the lessor has not been harmed by the omission.
Article 7:253 Objections against a proposal to increase
the rent
- 1. If the lessee, prior to the date on which
the increase of the rental price should have taken effect according to
the proposal of the lessor, declares in writing that he does not agree
with that proposal, then the lessor may up to six weeks after that date,
under submission of a duplicate of his proposal and of the aforementioned
written declaration of the lessee, request the rent committee to determine
whether his proposal to increase the rent is reasonable. If the lessor
has made a proposal as referred to in Article 252a, paragraph 1, and the
declaration referred to in the first sentence refers to the household
income, then the lessor requests the inspector for a second declaration
as referred to in Article 252a, paragraph 4. If a request is made as referred to in the first sentence, the lessor shall also submit the second declaration.
- 2. During three months after the day referred
to in paragraph 1, the lessee may request the rent committee to give its
decision on the reasonableness of the proposal of the lessor:
a. if he has not made a written declaration
prior to the date mentioned in paragraph 1, first sentence, nor has created
the impression by paying the proposed increase of the rent, to agree with
that increase, and;
b. the lessor has informed him about the proposal
once again within six weeks after the date referred to in paragraph 1
by registered letter to which a duplicate of the proposal has been added,
and he has not agreed with the proposal to increase the rent. When making
his request to the rent committee, the lessee must submit a duplicate
of the proposal and of that registered letter and, where the lessor has
made a proposal referred to in Article 7:252a, paragraph 1, and the household
income is the subject of the disagreement, data relating to that household
income. Paragraph 1, third sentence, applies accordingly.
- 3. The lessee is presumed to have come to
an agreement with the lessor over the proposed increase of the rent as
of the proposed day on which the increase takes effect according tot the
proposal, when he, after he has received the registered letter meant in
paragraph 2 under point (b), has not addressed a request to the rent committee
within three days after the day from which the increase shall take effect
according to the proposal of the lessor.
- 4. When the lessee makes a request meant
in paragraph 2, the rent committee shall inform the lessor immediately
of it.
- 5. When the lessor has made a proposal as
meant in Article 7:252, paragraph 1, or Article 7:252a, paragraph 1, by registered letter, and the requirements
of paragraph 2, under (a), have been met, the lessor may within six
weeks after the day referred to in paragraph 1, first sentence, request the rent committee
to give its decision about the reasonableness of the proposal. When making
his request to the rent committee, the lessor must submit a duplicate
of his proposal and a proof that it has been made by registered letter
to the lessee.
Article 7:254 Decrease of the rent
If the lessor does not agree with a proposal of the lessee to reduce the
rent, then the lessee may, up to six weeks after the day as of which the
reduction should have become effective according to his proposal, request
the rent committee to give its decision about the reasonableness of the
proposal.
Article 7:255 Increase of the rent after a housing
improvement
- 1. The rent of a residential space in which
or to which during the lease period by or because of the lessor:
a. facilities have been placed which are related
to measures intending to lift or reduce restrictions which a disabled
person encounters when using the residential space in a normal way, for
the expenditures of which a statutory regulation only grants a partial
financial compensation, or;
b. changes or additives have been added for
another reason than to remedy defects as meant in Article 7:204, through
which the residential comfort is regarded to have been improved and which
are not covered already by the provision under point (a),
equals the agreed rent, multiplied with an amount which is in reasonable
proportion to the costs of these facilities, changes or additives, made
by the lessor, on the understanding that the total rent cannot be higher
than the rent which under Article 10 paragraph 1 of the Implementation
Act on Housing Rent is regarded as reasonable.
- 2. If parties have not come to an agreement
over the amount of the increase, then each of them may request the rent
committee, within three months after the facilities, changes or additives
have been brought about, to give its decision about the amount of the
increase.
- 3. By a disabled persons, as referred to
in paragraph 1, is understood a person who experiences perceptible restrictions
as a result of a disease or disorder.
Article 7:256 [repealed on 01-04-2007]
Article 7:257 Maintenance procedure
- 1. The legal claim (right of action) of
the lessee to request a reduction of the rent on the basis of Article
7:207, paragraph 1, in connection with Article 7:242, is subject to a
peremptory time limit of six months after the day following the one on
which the lessee has informed the lessor about the defect, taking into
account as well the following paragraphs.
- 2. Where the legal claim (right of action)
of the lessee is based on a non-performance of the lessor which by virtue
of Article 7:241 is regarded as a defect, the lessee may not only file
his claim at the court within the period meant in paragraph 1, but he
may instead as well request the rent committee to give its decision about
the reduction of the rent in accordance with the Order in Council meant
in Article 16 paragraph 2 of the Implementation Act on Housing Rent, which
request must be made within six months after the day following the one
on which the lessee has informed the lessor about the defect. The lessee
may only address such a request to the rent committee if the lessor has
not remedied the defect within six weeks after the day following the one
on which he was informed about the defect by the lessee.
- 3. After the expiration of the six month
period meant in the previous paragraphs, no reduction of the rent can
be requested, as far as it concerns the past, over a period longer than
six months prior to the moment on which the legal claim was filed at the
court or on which the request was made to the rent committee.
§ 2. Other compensations
Article 7:258 All-in lease price
If the lease agreement includes more than just a right of use of a residential
space, but it only mentions the overall lease price and not the rent,
then the rent committee may, upon the request of the lessee, determine
both, the rent as well as the amount payable in advance as service charges.
Such a request may be lodged also by the lessor if the agreed lease price
is less than 55 % of the maximum rent limit under Article 10 paragraph
1 of the Implementation Act on Housing Rent.
Article 7:259 Service charges
- 1. The obligation of the lessee to pay service
charges goes up to the amount as agreed upon by the lessee and the lessor
or, when they fail to come to terms on it, to the amount that is in line
with the applying statutory provisions or with what can be regarded as
a reasonable compensation for the provided goods and services.
- 2. Each year, at the latest six months after
the expiration of a calendar year, the lessor hands over to the lessee
an overview of the charged service charges, itemized to their components,
with indication of the way that they are calculated. If costs have been
charged to the lessor that do not affect a calendar year, but another
period of twelve months, being a financial year that ends in the expired
calendar year, then the lessor shows the costs over that other period
in the overview of the expired calendar year.
- 3. The overview meant in paragraph 2 relates
at the end of the lease agreement to the period of the calendar year that
already had expired at that moment.
- 4. When asked for at the end of the lease
agreement, the lessor must offer the lessee the possibility, after the
overview meant in paragraph 2 has been handed over, to inspect the books
and other supporting documents or duplicates thereof underlying this overview.
Article 7:260 Service charge procedure
- 1. If the lessee and lessor have not come
to terms on the obligation of the lessee to pay service charges, then
the lessee or lessor may request the rent committee to give its decision
about this issue.
- 2. The request is related to one period
of no longer than twelve months for each cost category to which the request
is related. The request can be made up to twenty-four months after the
moment on which the period for handing over an overview by the lessor
as mentioned in Article 7:259, paragraph 2, has expired.
Article 7:261 Advance payment of service charges
- 1. Unless parties have agreed otherwise
after the lease agreement has taken effect, the services charges, payable
by the lessee in advance under the lease agreement or a judicial decision,
can only be raised:
a. as of the day following the end of the term
of payment during which an additional provision of goods or services has
been agreed upon or as of the start of the term of payment during which
these additional provision of goods or services shall take effect;
b. as of the day following the end of the term
of payment during which the last overview, meant in Article 7:259, has
been handed over to the lessee, on the understanding that each overview
can only once lead to an increase.
- 2. The lessee is bound by a change in the
provided goods or services and to an adjustment of the amount of the advance
payment that goes with it, if that change is related to goods or services
that can only be provided jointly to a number of lessees, and at least
70% of those lessees have agreed with this change. A lessee who has not
agreed with the change in the provided goods or services may, within eight
weeks after the written notification of the lessor that he has come to
an agreement over this change with at least 70% of the lessees, demand
a decision of the court with regard to the reasonableness of the proposal.
- 3. If the advance payment due by the lessee
is considerably higher than the to be expected service charges, then the
rent committee may reduce the amount of the advance payment upon the request
of the lessee to an amount which is in reasonable proportion to those
service charges.
§ 3. Final provisions
Article 7:262 Legal claim (right of action) to be
filed at the Subdistrict Court
- 1. When the rent committee has given its
decision on a request of the lessee or lessor as meant in § 1 and
§ 2 of this Subsection (Subsection 7.4.5.2), the lessee and lessor
are presumed to have come to an agreement with each other over what has
been determined in this decision, unless one of them has demanded a judgment
of the Subdistrict Court on the issue about which the rent committee was
requested to give its decision, which legal claim must be filed at the
Subdistrict Court within eight weeks after a duplicate of the decision
of the rent committee was sent to the parties.
- 2. No appeal to a higher court is open against
a judgment of the Subdistrict Court rendered under the present Article
Article 7:263 Commencing date of the increased or
reduced rent
An increase or reduction of the rent, assessed by a decision of the rent
committee or a judgment of the court, may be charged as from the day on
which the increase or reduction should have taken effect according to
the proposal of the lessor or lessee or, when the rent is changed without
a proposal has been made to this end, as from the day on which the rent
committee has been asked to give its decision on it or as from the day
on which the legal claim has been filed at the Subdistrict Court to obtain
a judgment on it. Where the decision of the rent committee or the judgment
of the Subdistrict Court mentions a later day as of which the increase
or reduction of the rent may be charged, this day will be the commencing
day for the rent increase or rent reduction.
Article 7:264 Stipulated unreasonable advantage for
one of the parties or a third person
- 1. Each contractual provisional about something
differently than the rent, stipulated in relation with the conclusion
of a lease agreement on a residential space, is null and void, insofar
it grants an unreasonable advantage to one of the parties.
- 2. Each contractual provision stipulated
in relation with the conclusion of a lease agreement in relation to a
residential space, is null and void, insofar it grants an unreasonable
advantage to a third person or insofar it compels a third person to grant
an unreasonable advantage.
Article 7:265 Mandatory law
It is not possible to derogate from the provisions of this Subsection
(Subsection 7.4.5.2), unless these provisions imply differently.
Subsection 7.4.5.3 Joint lease and continuation
of the lease agreement
Article 7:266 Joint lease of the spouse or registered
partner
- 1. The spouse or registered partner of the
lessee is by operation of law a co-lessee, as long as the leased residential
space is the main residence of the spouse or registered partner, irrespective
whether the marriage or registered partnership was entered into before
or after the lease agreement.
- 2. The spouse or registered partner is towards
the lessor joint and several liable for the obligations arising from the
lease agreement, except as far as these obligations were already due and
demandable before the spouse or registered partner became a co-lessee.
- 3. If the lease agreement has come to an
end for the lessee, then the co-lessee automatically becomes the lessee.
- 4. If the spouse or registered partner meant
in paragraph 1 does not have the use of the leased marital residence,
either pursuant to a judicial decision as referred to in Article 826,
paragraph 1 under point (a) of the Code of Civil Procedure, or pursuant
to a mutual request for a divorce or legal separation or pursuant to the
ending of the registered partnership, then this does not lead to a change
of his main residence for the purpose of the present Article.
- 5. In the event of a divorce or legal separation
or the ending of registered partnership the court may, upon the request
of a spouse or registered partner, ascertain who of the spouses or registered
partners will be the lessee of the residential space. The court determines
as well the commencing day of the lease agreement with this spouse or
registered partner. On the same day the lease agreement with the other
spouse or registered partner has ended.
Article 7:267 Joint lease of other persons living
together
- 1. When the lessee and another person who
has his main residence in the leased residential space and with whom the
lessee runs a joint household, have together requested the lessor if this
other person may become a co-lessee, and the lessor has not agreed with
this request within three months in writing, then the lessee and this
other person may jointly claim in court that this other person will become
a co-lessee as of a day to be determined in the judgment of the court.
If the residential space is not only the main residence of the lessee
and this other person, but also of a co-lessee, then the request to the
lessor as wel as the legal claim in court must be made jointly by the
lessee, the co-lessee and the other person who wants to become a co-lessee
too.
- 2. After a request has been made to the
lessor as meant in paragraph 1, the court can no longer award a legal
claim to rescind the lease agreement as far as it is filed on the ground
that the lessee, in violation of what was agreed upon, runs together with
this other person a joint household in the leased residential space. Neither
can this then be a ground for termination of the lease agreement.
- 3. The court may only reject the legal claim
meant in paragraph 1:
a. if the person meant in paragraph 1 does
not have his main residence in the leased residential space for at least
two years or if he does not run a joint household with the lessee in this
residential space for at least two years;
b. if, also with regard to what has been ascertained
about the joint household and its duration, the legal claim apparently
just has the purpose to grant the person meant in paragraph 1 the quality
of co-lessee on a short term;
c. if the person meant in paragraph 1 provides,
from a financial point of view, insufficient certainty that he is able
to comply with his obligation to pay the rent properly.
- 4. The person who has entered into the lease
agreement and every person that has become a lessee or co-lessee by virtue
of the present Article, are joint and several liable towards the lessor
for all obligations arising from the lease agreement, on the understanding
that a co-lessee is not liable for obligations which were already due
and demandable before he became a co-lessee.
- 5. Contractual and statutory provisions
concerning the end of the lease agreement apply to all persons meant in
paragraph 4 separately, on the understanding that a person in any case
loses his quality of co-lessee if he no longer has his main residence
in the leased residential space. If the lease agreement has come to an
end for the lessee, then the co-lessee automatically becomes the lessee.
- 6. If Chapter II of the Housing Act applies
to a residential space, then contrary to paragraph 5 the co-lessee only
continues the lease if the court has decided so on a legal claim, filed
for this purpose within eight weeks after the moment on which he has become
a lessee, and in any event as long as no final and binding judgment has
been given on this legal claim. The court may only reject the legal claim
if the person who has filed it, does not submit a housing license that
is to be issued to himself, as meant in Article 7 paragraph 1 of the Housing
Act.
- 7. Each of the persons meant in paragraph
4 may claim in court that one or more of these persons shall no longer
continue the lease agreement as of a day to be determined in the court's
judgment. The court may only grant the claim if, in fairness and with
due observance of the specific circumstances, this is necessary, on the
understanding that it must grant the claim if the plaintiff shows that
the person to which the legal claim relates has acquired the quality of
co-lessee on the basis of a request to the lessor that was not made by
the plaintiff also or on the basis of a legal claim in court as meant
in paragraph 1 that was not filed by the plaintiff too.
Article 7:268 Position of the co-lessee and other
occupants after the death of the lessee
- 1. Upon the death of the lessee, the co-lessee
automatically continues the lease agreement as being the lessee. He may
terminate the lease agreement within six months after the death of the
deceased lessee by bailiff's notification or registered letter, ending
the lease as of the first day of the second month after the termination
was announced.
- 2. A person who has his main residence in
the leased residential space and with whom the deceased lessee had run
a joint household, but who has not become a lessee by virtue of paragraph
1, continues the lease agreement for six months after the death of the
deceased lessee; the second sentence of paragraph 1 applies to him as
well. He continues the lease agreement also afterwards, if the court has
ordered so on a legal claim filed within that period for this purpose
and at least during the legal proceedings as long as the court has not
given a final and binding judgment on his legal claim.
- 3. The court must reject the legal claim
meant in paragraph 2:
a. if the plaintiff has not made plausible
that he meets the requirements of paragraph 2;
b. if the plaintiff, from a financial point
of view, provides insufficient certainty that he is able to comply with
the lease agreement;
c. if Chapter II of the Housing Act applies
to the leased residential space and the plaintiff fails to submit a housing
license that is issued to himself as meant in Article 7 paragraph 1 of
the Housing Act.
- 4. Paragraph 4, paragraph 5, first sentence
and paragraph 7 of Article 7:267 apply accordingly to the co-lessee or
other occupant meant in the present Article.
- 5. Where it is ascertained that a person
has wrongly claimed the continuation of the lease agreement on the basis
of the present Article, he remains over the time during which he has had
the enjoyment of the residential space liable towards the lessor for the
compliance with the lease agreement that would have applied to him if
he had been a lessee. When two or more persons have wrongly claimed the
continuation of the lease agreement, each of them is joint and several
liable towards the lessor.
- 6. When there are no persons to continue
the lease agreement on the basis of the present Article, then this agreement
ends at the end of the second month after the death of the deceased lessee.
The heirs of the deceased lessee are entitled to terminate the lease agreement
at the end of the first month after the death of the deceased lessee.
When the estate (inheritance) of the deceased lessee is apportioned in
accordance with Article 4:13 of the Civil Code [intestate succession],
the right of the heirs to terminate the lease agreement meant in the previous
sentence belongs to the spouse or registered partner of the deceased lessee.
- 7. It is not possible to derogate from this
Article to the disadvantage of the persons to whom a right of continuation
of the lease agreement is granted under this Article, nor to the disadvantage
of the heirs or the spouse or registered partner of the deceased lessee
meant in paragraph 6.
- 8. It is not possible to derogate from Article 7:229, paragraph 1 and
3.
Article 7:269 Protection of the sublessee of a separate
dwelling
- 1. A sublease agreement related to a separate
dwelling where the sublessee has his main residence, is continued by the
lessor in the event that the lease agreement between the lessee and lessor
ends.
- 2. Within six months after the lessor has
continued the sublease agreement pursuant to paragraph 1, he may claim
in court that the sublease agreement shall end as of a day to be mentioned
in the judgement of the court on the ground that:
a. the sublessee, from a financial point of
view, provides insufficient certainty that he is able to comply with the
sublease agreement;
b. the sublease agreement has been concluded
with the apparent purpose to grant the sublessee the quality of lessee;
c. in the given circumstances to standards
of reasonableness and fairness, taking into account also the usual content
of lease agreements related to similar residential spaces and the content
of the lease agreement between the lessee and lessor that has ended, as
well as the content of the continued sublease agreement, it cannot be
expected of the lessor that he continues the sublease agreement with the
sublessee;
d. Chapter II of the Housing Act applies to
the leased residential space and the sublessee fails to submit a housing
license that is issued to himself as meant in Article 7 paragraph 1 of
the Housing Act.
- 3. Where a sublease agreement relates to
a residential space, regardless whether this is a separate or a dependant
dwelling, the person who on the basis of Articles 7:266, 7:267 or 7:268
has become the lessee or has continued the lease agreement, continues
the sublease agreement with the sublessee.
Article 7:270 Exchange of houses
- 1. The lessee who wishes to bring about
an exchange of houses, may claim in court to get authorized to make someone
else instead of himself the lessee of the residential space which he has
leased. If Chapter II of the Housing Act applies to the residential space
he has leased, then he must submit a housing license as meant in Article
7 paragraph 1 of the Housing Act that is issued to the proposed lessee
who will take his place.
- 2. The court decides in consideration of
the specific circumstances, on the understanding that it may award the
claim only if the lessee has a compelling interest in the exchange of
houses, and that it rejects the claim if the proposed lessee, from a financial
point of view, provides insufficient certainty that he is able to comply
with the lease agreement properly. The court may, in addition, subject
its authorisation to certain conditions or impose specific instructions
on the lessee or on the proposed lessee who will take his place.
- 3. It is not possible to derogate to the
disadvantage of the lessee from the present Article.
Article 7:270a Information duty
In the event that a lease agreement is continued pursuant to Articles
7:266, 7:268 or 7:269, the person who continues the lease agreement is
obliged to inform the lessor about this.
Subsection 7.4.5.4 The end of a lease agreement
Article 7:271 Termination of the lease of a residential
space
- 1. Contrary to Article 7:228 paragraph 1,
a lease agreement related to a residential space that has been entered
into for a fixed term does not end on the expiry of the lease period;
it may be terminated by each of the parties by means of a notice of termination
taking effect as of a termination date which is an agreed rent payment
day, not being a date before the moment on which the fixed lease period
has expired.
- 2. A lease agreement related to a residential
space that has been entered into or continued for an indefinite term may
be terminated by each of the parties by means of a notice of termination
taking effect as of a termination date which is an agreed rent payment
day.
- 3. The notice of termination effectuating
the termination must be a bailiff's notification or a registered letter.
Where pursuant to Article 7:266 the spouse or registered partner of the
lessee is a co-lessee, the notice of termination must be addressed to
both spouses or both registered partners separately.
- 4. The notice of termination by the lessor
must, under penalty of nullity, mention the grounds which have lead to
the termination. A termination by the lessor based on other grounds than
those mentioned in Article 7:274 paragraph 1, is null and void. The lessee
must be asked in the notice of termination to report within six weeks
to the lessor if he does or does not agree with the ending of the lease
agreement.
- 5. In terminating the lease agreement the
following time periods must be observed:
a. if the lessee terminates the agreement:
a term of notice that is as long as the period between two succeeding
rent payment days set under the lease agreement, yet not shorter than
a month and not longer than three months;
b. if the lessor terminates the agreement:
a term of notice not shorter than three months, which is extended with
one month for each year that the lessee has continuously had the use of
the leased property under the lease agreement, but never longer than six
months.
- 6. A termination in violation of paragraph
1, paragraph 3 or paragraph 5 under point (a), and a termination on the
basis of a shorter term of notice than ordered in paragraph 5 under point
(b), are nevertheless regarded as a valid termination, but then as of
an effective termination date that as such is set by law and under observance
of the term of notice that as such is set by law.
- 7. Each contractual provision indicating
that the lessee has to observe a longer term of notice than the one meant
in paragraph 5 under point (a) or that the lessor enjoys a shorter term
of notice than the one meant in paragraph 5 under point (b) or derogating
from any other provision of the present Article, is null and void. Each
contractual provision ending the lease agreement without a prior termination,
is null and void.
- 8. The present Article has no relevance if
the lease agreement is ended with mutual consent of the parties at a moment
on which the lease agreement already had been entered into with binding
effect for both parties.
Article 7:272 Legal effect of a termination (claim
in court of the lessor)
- 1. As of the day on which a lease agreement
related to a residential space has been validly ended by termination,
it remains in force by operation of law until the court has given a final
and binding judgment on a legal claim of the lessor as meant in paragraph
2.
The previous sentence does not apply when the lessee has terminated the
lease agreement or when he has agreed with its ending in writing after
it was terminated by the lessor.
- 2. When the lessor has not received, within
six weeks after the effective termination date, a written notification
of the lessee that the lessee agrees with the ending of the lease agreement,
then the lessor may claim in court, on the grounds mentioned in the notice
of termination, that the court will determine the day on which the lease
agreement shall end.
Article 7:273 Legal effects when the legal claim of
the lessor is rejected or granted
- 1. In giving a judgment on a legal claim
meant in Article 7:272 paragraph 2, the court may only consider the grounds
mentioned in the notice of termination.
- 2. If the court rejects the legal claim
of the lessor, then the lease agreement is extended by operation of law.
The court decides whether the lease agreement is extended for an indefinite
term or for a fixed term.
- 3. If the court awards the legal claim of
the lessor, then it will also determine the day on which the leased property
must be evicted by the lessee. This decision is considered to be a judgment
in which the lessee is condemned to evict the leased property on that
day.
Article 7:274 Grounds for termination of the lease
of residential spaces
- 1. The court may only award a legal claim
of the lessor meant in Article 7:272 paragraph 2 :
a. if the lessee has not behaved himself as
a good lessee should;
b. if the lessor has based his legal claim
on a contractual clause as defined in paragraph 2 and the requirements
of that paragraph are met, unless the lessor no longer has an interest
in the eviction of the leased residential space;
c. if the lessor makes plausible that he is
so urgently in need of the use of the leased residential space himself,
for another reason than to alienate it, that to standards of reasonableness
and fairness, taking into account the interests of both parties and of
possible sublessees, it cannot be expected of him to continue the lease
agreement any longer, and it appears that the lessee, with exception of
the lessee referred to in paragraph 4, is able to obtain another appropriate
dwelling;
d. if the lessee does not accept a reasonable
offer to enter into a new lease agreement related to the same residential
space, as far as, in the event that Subsection 7.4.5.2 applies to the
terminated lease agreement, this offer does not imply a change of the
rent or of the service charges;
e. if the lessor wants to realize a specific
use of the leased property in accordance with a valid land use plan;
f. if the lease agreement relates to a dependant
residential space, which forms a part of the dwelling in which the lessor
has his main residence, and the lessee makes plausible that his interest
in ending the lease agreement weighs more heavily than the interest of
the lessee in continuing it.
- 2. In the event that the lessor has explicitly
stipulated in the lease agreement that the leased residential space must
be evicted after a period of time mentioned in the relevant contractual
clause, he may, in accordance with paragraph 1 under point (b), ground
his legal claim on such a contractual clause:
a. if he has never lived in the residential
space himself and he never has leased it out earlier, and he wants to
take up residence there himself after that period of time;
b. if he was the previous occupant of the leased
residential space himself and he wants to take up residence there again
after that period of time;
c. if he has granted the previous lessee the
right to take up residence again in the leased residential space after
that period of time and he wants to give this lessee access to the property.
- 3. The need of the lessor to use the leased
residential space himself in the sense of paragraph 1 under point (c)
also exists:
a. if he wants to renovate the leased residential
space and this is not possible without ending the lease agreement or;
b. if he wants to give a disabled person the
opportunity to take up residence in the leased residential space, provided
this is a separate dwelling that:
1°. already at its construction was functionally arranged and intended
to be occupied by a disabled person, or
2°. after its construction has been made fit for occupation by a disabled
person with financial support on the basis of a statutory regulation;
c. if he wants to give an elderly person the
opportunity to take up residence in the leased residential space, provided
this is a separate dwelling that forms a part of a residential estate
which already at its construction was functionally arranged and intended
to be occupied by elderly people;
In answering the question if another residential space is an appropriate
dwelling for the lessee, the court pays no attention the contributions
of the State which the lessee may obtain as a compensation for the rent
or costs he has to pay for the use of a residential space.
- 4. The need of the lessor to use the leased
residential space himself in the sense of paragraph 1 under point (c)
also exists when he wants to give a student the opportunity to take up
residence in the leased residential space if:
1°. that residential space by virtue of the lease agreement is intended
for students as meant in this paragraph;
2°. the lessee, against whom a legal claim as referred to in paragraph
1 has been filed, has not complied with a written request of the lessor,
which can be made annually, to hand over within three months a copy of
proof of his registration at an institution, a university or college as
meant in this paragraph for the current college year, and
3°. the lease agreement with the lessee against whom a legal claim
as referred to in paragraph 1 has been filed, stipulates that the residential
space, after this lease agreement has ended, shall be leased out again
to a student as meant in this paragraph.
In this paragraph by a student is understood: a participant who is registered
at an institution as meant in Article 1.1.1, component (b) of the Adult
and Vocational Education Act or a student who is registered at a university
or college as meant in Article 1.2, components (a) and (b) of the Act
on Higher Education and Scientific Education.
- 5. A legal claim, based on the need of the
lessor to use the leased residential space himself in the sense of paragraph
1 under point (c), is not awardable:
a. If Chapter II of the Housing Act applies
to the involved residential space, as long as the lessor has not submitted
a housing license that is issued to himself as meant in Article 7 paragraph
1 of the Housing Act, except when the need of the lessor to use the leased
residential space himself encloses something else than habitation;
b. if the lessor is the legal successor of
the previous lessor and the termination has occurred within three years
after the legal succession has been notified in writing of the lessee.
- 6. In the situations meant in paragraph
1 under point (a) and point (d), the court may, before it awards the legal
claim, grant the lessee a term of at the most one month to comply with
his obligations still or to accept the offer after all.
- 7. By a disabled person as meant in paragraph
3 is understood a person who experiences perceptible restrictions as a
result of a disease or disorder.
Article 7:275 Moving expenses and settling-in costs
- 1. When the court decides to award the legal
claim to end the lease agreement on the grounds for termination specified
in Article 7:274, paragraph 1 under point (c) and (e), it may assess an
amount which the lessor has to pay to the lessee as compensation for moving
expenses and settling-in costs which the lessee has to make.
- 2. Before the court gives a decision in which
this amount is determined, it may announce its intention to both parties
and set a period of time within which the lessor may withdraw the termination.
If the lessor uses this right of withdrawal, then the court shall only
give a judgment concerning the costs of proceedings.
- 3. Where the lease agreement has been terminated
on the grounds specified in Article 7:274, paragraph 1, under point (c),
in connection with Article 7:274, paragraph 3, under point (a) and Article
7:274, paragraph 1, under point (e), the lessor contributes in the costs
which the lessee has to make with regard to the relocation (moving expenses).
- 4. The minimum contribution in the costs
of relocation (moving expenses) and settling-in costs, to be made by lessees
of separate dwellings, mobile homes and mobile home stands, will be determined
by means of a Ministerial Decree of the Minister for Housing, Communities
and Integration and will be amended each year, before 1 March, as far
as the consumer price index (CPI) gives reason to do so. The amount mentioned
in the first sentence shall be rounded off upwards or downwards to whole
euros.
- 5. Contributions in or compensations for
moving expenses and settling-in costs, provided by the municipality to
the lessee, may be deducted from the contribution that the lessor has
to pay pursuant to paragraph 4.
Article 7:276 Liability when the lessor was not urgently
in need to use the residential space himself
- 1. If the lessor has terminated the lease
agreement on the ground meant in Article 7:274, paragraph 1 under point
(c), and the lessee has agreed on this basis with the ending of the lease
or the legal claim of the lessor to end the lease agreement on that ground
has been awarded by the court, then the lessor is liable towards the lessee
for damages if it appears that the lessor in reality never has been urgently
in need of the use of the leased residential space himself.
- 2. Subject to counter-evidence, the lessor
is regarded never to have been urgently in need of the use of the leased
residential space himself, if he does not permanently uses the residential
space himself within one year after the lease agreement was ended.
- 3. If the court awards a legal claim of
the lesser to end the lease agreement on the ground of termination meant
in Article 7:274, paragraph 1 under point (c), it may, upon the request
of the lessee or of its own motion, set an amount which the lessor has
to pay to the lessee if it has become apparent afterwards that the lessor
in reality never has been urgently in need of the use of the leased residential
space himself, notwithstanding the right of the lessee to claim further
damages.
- 4. The legal claim for compensation which
the lessee may have by virtue of the present Article becomes prescribed
five years after the lease agreement has ended.
- 5. In the situations meant in the previous
paragraphs, the lessor has to pay compensatory damages as well to sublessees
to whom the leased residential space or a part thereof was rightfully
subleased or who were entitled to continue their agreement with the main
lessor by virtue of Article 7:269. The previous paragraphs apply in that
event accordingly.
Article 7:277 End of the lease agreement after it
has been extended
- 1. If the court has extended the lease agreement,
then the lessor may terminate it again with due observance of Article
7:271 and the terms of notice mentioned in paragraph 2 of the present
Article and he may file a legal claim in accordance with Articles 7:272
up to and including 7:274 in which he asks the court to set the date on
which the lease agreement shall end.
- 2. If the court has extended the lease agreement
for an indefinite term, then the lessor cannot terminate it again before
three years have expired since the day on which this judgment has become
final and binding. If the court has extended the lease agreement for a
fixed term, then the lessor may terminate it again, but no sooner than
three months before the end of the fixed term with which it was extended.
Article 7:278 Legal effects of the end of the main
lease agreement for a sublessee
- 1. A sublease agreement with respect to
a residential space that could not be continued on the basis of Article
7:269 after the main lease agreement has been ended by the main lessor,
ends on the day on which the main lessee must evict the residential space
according to a judgment of the court on a legal claim of the main lessor
filed on the basis of Article 7:273, paragraph 3.
- 2. If the main lessee has not watched over
the interests of the sublessee sufficiently when the main lease agreement
was ended or when the date was set on which he must evict the residential
space, then he is obliged to compensate the damage which the sublessee
has suffered as a result.
- 3. The main lessee against whom the main
lessor has filed a legal claim which affects the interests of the sublessee,
is entitled to call the sublessee to court.
Article 7:279 Rescission of a lease agreement with
respect to a condemned or dangerous dwelling
- 1. If the part of the leased residential
space that the lessee and his family necessarily have to use for occupation
is unfit for habitation due to a defect in the sense of Article 7:204
or if repair activities to remedy this defect make or will make that part
uninhabitable, then the lessee is entitled to rescind the lease agreement
on the basis of Article 6:267 of the Civil Code.
- 2. The lessee has the same possibilities
when the use of the leased residential space has become dangerous.
- 3. Article 7:210, paragraph 2, applies accordingly.
Article 7:280 Respite period
Before rescinding the lease agreement on the basis of Article 7:231, the
court may permit the lessee a period of at the most one month to meet
his obligations.
Article 7:281 Rescission of a lease agreement to realize
an allowed land use of the leased property
- 1. If someone has become a lessor on the
basis of Article 7:226 and he wants to realize a specific use for the
leased property in accordance with a valid land use plan, then the court
shall, on a legal claim of the lessor, rescind the lease agreement as
of a date to be set in its judgement.
- 2. The lessee and the sublessee to whom
the leased property was subleased rightfully or with whom the lease agreement
otherwise would have been continued on the basis of Article 7:269, are
entitled to compensatory damages. If the lease period or sublease period
would have proceeded for at least one year when the agreement would not
have been rescinded, then the compensatory damages are at least as much
as the rent of two years. If the lease period or sublease period would
have proceeded for less than one year when the agreement would not have
been rescinded, then the compensatory damages are at least as much as
the rent of one year. In calculating the damage no attention is paid to
changes to the leased property which apparently were made to increase
the compensatory damages.
Article 7:282 Mandatory law
It is not possible to derogate to the disadvantage of the lessee or sublessee
from Articles 7:272 up to and including 7:281
[Articles 7:283 - 7:289 reserved for possible additional legislation]
Section 7.4.6 Lease of retail spaces
Article 7:290 Application with regard to 'retail spaces'
- 1. The provisions of this Section (Section
7.4.6) apply to lease agreements with regard to retail spaces.
- 2. By a 'retail space' is understood:
a. a constructed immovable thing or a part
thereof which under a lease agreement is intended to be used for a retail
trade business, shop, restaurant, café or bar, private take away
or delivery service or the trade of craft works, provided that the leased
space entails a room which is open to the public for direct supply of
goods or direct provision of services;
b. a constructed immovable thing or a part
thereof which under a lease agreement is intended to be used as a hotel;
c. an immovable thing which under a lease agreement
is intended to be used as a camping site business.
- 3. To a retail space as referred to in paragraph
2 also belong the immovable accessories of such space, the accompanying
land and, taking into account the use for which the retail space is intended,
an accessory house.
Article 7:291 Semi-mandatory law
- 1. It is not possible to derogate to the
disadvantage of the lessee from the provisions of this Section (Section
7.4.6).
- 2. Contractual provision that derogate to
the disadvantage of the lessee from the provisions of this Section (Section
7.4.6) can nevertheless not be nullified on that ground if they have been
approved by the court, except where it concerns a derogation from Article
7:307.
- 3. Each of the parties may request for such
an approval of the court. The approval is only given if the contractual
provision does not damage the elementary rights which the lessee derives
from this Section (Section 7.4.6) or if his social position in comparison
with that of the lessor is as such that he reasonably does not need the
protection of the present Section (Section 7.4.6).
- 4. The request contains, besides the grounds
on which it rests, the text of the to be approved contractual provision.
Article 7:292 Initial lease period and extended lease
period
- 1. The lease agreement with regard to a
retail space has a duration of five years or, if a longer fixed term has
been agreed upon, this longer duration.
- 2. If the initial lease period is five year,
then after its expiration the lease agreement will be extended by operation
of law with a second lease period of five years. If the initial lease
period was longer than five years, but less than ten years, then after
its expiration the lease agreement will be extended by operation of law
with a second lease period which is so much shorter than five years as
the initial lease period was longer than five years [the initial and second
lease period amount together up to ten years].
Article 7:293 Terms of notice and termination formalities
- 1. The lease agreement with regard to a
retail space that has a duration of five years or that has a duration
longer than five years, but less than ten years, may be terminated by
each of the parties by means of a notice of termination taking effect
as of a termination date at the end of the initial lease period or at
the end of the extended lease period meant in Article 7:292, paragraph
2. Article 7:228, paragraph 1 and 2, first sentence, do not apply.
- 2. The notice of termination effectuating
the termination must be a bailiff's notification or a registered letter.
The term of notice is at least one year.
- 3. No termination is required when the lease
agreement is ended with mutual consent of the parties at a moment on which
the lease agreement already had been entered into with binding effect
for both parties.
Article 7:294 Mentioning the grounds for termination
The notice of termination by the lessor is null and void if it does not
mention the grounds which have lead to the termination.
Article 7:295 Legal effects of a termination (claim
in court of the lessor)
- 1. As of the day on which a lease agreement
related to a retail space has been validly ended by termination, it remains
in force by operation of law until the court has given a final and binding
judgment on a legal claim of the lessor as meant in paragraph 2. However,
if the defence of the lessee appears to be unfounded, the court may give
a judgment which is enforceable immediately. The previous two sentences
do not apply when the lessee has terminated the lease agreement or when
he has agreed with its ending in writing after it was terminated by the
lessor.
- 2. When the lessor has not received, within
six weeks after the effective termination date, a written notification
of the lessee that the lessee agrees with the ending of the lease agreement,
the lessor may claim in court, on the grounds mentioned in the notice
of termination, that the court determines the day on which the lease agreement
shall end.
Article 7:296 Grounds for termination
- 1. If the lease agreement is terminated
at an effective termination date at the end of the initial lease period
meant in Article 7:292, paragraph 1, then the legal claim of the lessor
may be awarded only by the court on the ground that:
a. the conduct of business of the lessee has
not been in accordance with that of a good lessee, or
b. the lessor has made plausible that he, his
spouse, his registered partner, a blood relative in the direct line, an
in-law in the direct line or a foster child wants to take permanent use
of the leased retail space personally and the lessor is therefore in urgent
need of the retail space himself. By permanent use is understood also
the use for renovation of the retail space as far as this is not possible
without ending the lease agreement, but it does not include the alienation
of the retail space.
- 2. A legal claim, filed on the basis of
paragraph 1, under point (b), is not awardable if the lessor is the legal
successor of a previous lessor of whom he is not the spouse, the registered
partner, a blood relative in the first degree, an in-law in the first
degree or a foster child, and the termination is done within three years
after this legal succession was notified in writing to the lessee. By
a foster child is understood a person who has been taken care for and
raised as an own child.
- 3. If the lease agreement has been extended
under Article 7:292, paragraph 2, with a second lease period and the lessor
terminates it by means of a notice of termination taking effect as of
a termination date at the end of this second period, then the court may
award his legal claim after a reasonable appreciation of the lessor's
interests in ending the lease agreement and the lessee's interests in
continuing the lease agreement, taking into account as well the interests
of possible sublessees to whom the retail space or a part thereof has
been rightfully subleased. If a reasonable comparison between on the one
hand the before-mentioned interests of the lessee and sublessee and on
the other hand the before-mentioned interests of the lessor leads to the
conclusion that the lessee cannot be expected to evict the leased retail
space, then the court must reject the legal claim of the lessor.
- 4. In the event meant in paragraph 3, the
court must award the legal claim of the lessor, regardless the outcome
of a reasonable comparison of the interests of the involved parties, if:
a. the conduct of business of the lessee has
not been in accordance with that of a good lessee;
b. the lessor has made plausible that he or
one of the persons meant in paragraph 1, under point (b), wants to take
permanent use of the leased retail space personally and the lessor is
therefore in urgent need of the retail space, provided that the provision
in paragraph 2 does not stand in the way;
c. the lessee does not accept a reasonable
offer to enter into a new agreement with regard to the leased retail space
as far as this offer does not imply a change of the rent, or;
d. the lessor wants to realize a specific use
of the leased property in accordance with a valid land use plan.
- 5. If the court awards the legal claim of
the lessor, then it will also determine the day on which the leased retail
space must be evicted by the lessee. This decision is considered to be
a judgment in which the lessee is condemned to evict the leased property
on that day.
Article 7:297 Moving expenses and settling-in costs
- 1. In its decision to award the legal claim
of the lessor to end the lease agreement, the court may assess an amount
which the lessor has to pay to the lessee or to a person to whom the retail
space or a part of it has been rightfully subleased as compensation for
moving expenses and settling-in costs which the lessee or this sublessee
has to make.
- 2. Before giving a decision in which an
amount is assessed as meant in paragraph 1, the court will announce its
intention to all involved parties and set a period of time within which
the lessor may withdraw his termination.
- 3. If the lessor uses his right of withdrawal
within the set period, then the court shall only give a judgment concerning
the costs of proceedings.
Article 7:298 Respite period to accept the offer of
the lessor
In the event, meant in Article 7:296, paragraph 4, under point (c), the
court may permit the lessee a period of at the most one month during which
he still can accept the offer to enter into a new agreement.
Article 7:299 Liability when the proposed person never
wanted to take permanent use of the leased retail space personally
- 1. If the lease agreement has been terminated
on the ground that a person, meant in Article 7:296, paragraph 1, under
point (b), wants to take permanent use of the leased retail space personally,
and the lessee has agreed on this ground with the ending of the lease
or the legal claim of the lessor to end the lease agreement has been awarded
by the court on this ground or on the ground meant in Article 7:296, paragraph
3, then the lessor is liable for damages towards the lessee and towards
the person to whom the retail space or a part thereof was rightfully subleased,
if it appears that the proposed person meant in Article 7:296, paragraph
1, under point (b), in reality never wanted to take permanent use of the
leased retail space personally.
- 2. Subject to counter-evidence, the proposed
person meant in Article 7:296, paragraph 1, under point (b), is regarded
never to have wanted to take permanent use of the leased retail space
personally, if he does not permanently uses the retail space himself within
one year after the lease agreement was ended.
- 3. If the court awards the legal claim of
the lessor to end the lease agreement on the ground of termination meant
in Article 7:296, paragraph 1, under point (b), it may, upon the request
of the lessee or of its own motion, set an amount which the lessor has
to pay to the lessee or to a person to whom the retail space or a part
thereof has been rightfully subleased, if it becomes apparent that the
proposed person meant in Article 7:296, paragraph 1, under point (b),
never wanted to take permanent use of the leased retail space personally,
notwithstanding the right of the lessee to claim further damages.
- 4. The right of action of the lessee or
sublessee to claim damages or the payment of the amount referred to in
paragraph 3 becomes prescribed five years after the lease agreement has
ended.
Article 7:300 Termination of the lease after the second
lease period has expired
- 1. If the initial lease period has been
extended under Article 7:292, paragraph 2, with a second lease period
and the lease agreement has not been terminated at a date at the end of
that second period, then the lease agreement as from then is continued
for an indefinite term, unless the lease agreement implies that in such
an event it will be continued for a fixed term or parties have agreed
as such in another way.
- 2. After the lease agreement has been continued
for an indefinite term under paragraph 1, each of the parties may terminate
it. If the lease agreement is continued for a fixed term or if the initially
agreed lease period has a duration of ten years or more, then, contrary
to the provision of Article 7:228, paragraph 1, it will not end on the
expiry of that lease period, but each of the parties may terminate it
at a date at the end of that lease period.
- 3. The notice of termination must meet the
requirements of Article 7:293, paragraph 2 and 3, and of Article 7:294.
Articles 7:295 up to and including 7:299 apply accordingly.
- 4. If a legal claim to assess the date on
which the lease agreement shall end, has been rejected by the court, and
the lease agreement does not indicate that in such an event it will be
continued for a fixed term with the possibility to terminate it at a date
at the end of this term, then the lease agreement may only be terminated
again after a period of at least one year since the judgment in which
the legal claim was rejected has become final and binding. The court may
set a longer period in the judgment in which the legal claim was rejected.
Article 7:301 Lease period of two years or less
- 1. Articles 7:291 up to and including 7:300
do not apply to a lease agreement with an initial lease period of two
years or less.
- 2. If the use of the retail space, started
under an agreement as meant in paragraph 1, has exceeded a period of two
years, then the lease agreement is converted by operation of law into
an agreement under the same conditions, yet for five years, from which
the already expired two years are deducted. Articles 7:291 up to and including
7:300 apply to this agreement.
- 3. The legal effect meant in paragraph 2,
does not set in if parties, before the initial lease period of two years
has expired, have entered into another lease agreement which falls within
the scope of Article 7:292, paragraph 1, or have requested the court for
an approval as referred to in Article 7:291 to enter into a different
lease agreement.
- 4. Where parties, before the initial lease
period of two years has expired, have requested the court for an approval
to incorporate derogating contractual provisions in their lease agreement
on the basis of Article 7:291, and this is rejected by the court, the
court may, upon the request of the lessor, in addition decide that the
lease agreement shall end at a specific date and that the lessee must
have evicted the retail space at this moment. Such a decision is considered
to be a judgment to evict the leased property on this moment.
Article 7:302 Termination by the heirs, the spouse
or the registered partner of the lessee
A termination of the lease agreement by the heirs of the lessee or his
spouse or registered partner, on the basis of Article 7:229, paragraph
2, must be done with due observance of a term of notice of at least six
months. Article 7:293, paragraph 2, first sentence, and paragraph 3, apply
to this termination.
Article 7:303 Assessment of the rent by the court
- 1. Both, the lessee and lessor, may claim
in court that the rent is not in agreement with the rent of comparable
retail spaces in the vicinity and ask the court to assess the concerning
rent on that ground more specifically:
a. if the lease agreement is entered into for
a fixed term: after the agreed lease period has expired;
b. in all other events: each time when at least
five years have expired since the day on which the last rent, as set by
parties or the court, has become effective.
- 2. In assessing the rent more specifically,
the court pays attention to the average of the rent of similar retail
spaces in the vicinity of the involved retail space over the last five
years before the legal claim was filed. Each rent involved in the rent
comparison is recalculated according to the general development of the
rent level since the day on which that rent applied until the day on which
the legal claim was filed. If it appears to be impossible to provide the
court with the data required for the application of this standard of comparison,
then the court makes an estimation by means of the data which are available,
where it will take that standard as much as possible as a guideline.
- 3. The court rejects a legal claim to increase
the rent as far as it is based on improvements of the leased retail space
that have been introduced at the expense of the lessee.
- 4. If the court assesses the rent more specifically,
then this rent will become effective as of the day on which the relevant
legal claim was filed in court, unless the court has awarded a claim of
one of the parties to point out another commencing day in light of particular
circumstances of the situation. Moreover, the court may order in its judgment
that the rent will be changed gradually during a set period of at the
most five years.
Article 7:304 Expert opinion
- 1. A legal claim to assess the rent more
specifically as meant in Article 7:303, is only admissible if it is attended
with an advisory report about the level of the involved rent from one
or more experts in this field, selected by both parties.
- 2. When parties cannot come to terms on
the selection of an expert, the court will appoint him upon the request
of the most interested party. For the purpose of Article 7:303, paragraph
1, 2 and 4, the day on which such a request is lodged, is considered to
be the day on which the legal claim to assess the rent more specifically
is filed.
- 3. The costs of the advisory report are
treated as costs of proceedings as meant in Article 237 of the Code of
Civil Procedure; Articles 195, 196, 199 and 244 of that Code apply accordingly.
Article 7:305 Increase of the rent after applying
energy saving measures
- 1. The lessor who pursuant to an ordinance
as meant in Article 13 or 15 of the Housing Act has made energy saving
improvements as meant in Article 7:243, paragraph 2, to the leased retail
space, is entitled, also in situations falling outside the scope of Article
7:303, paragraph 1, under point (a) and (b), to recharge the costs of
these measures, as far as they are reasonable, to the lessee by charging
a higher rent. Where the lessee and lessor cannot come to terms on the
increase of the rent, each of them may claim in court the assessment of
this increase.
- 2. The present Article not only applies
to retail spaces in the sense of Article 7:290, but also to a constructed
immovable thing or a part thereof that is leased with the intention to
be used for another kind of business or enterprise than the ones mentioned
in Article 7:290.
Article 7:306 Legal effect of the end of the main
lease agreement for a sublessee
- 1. A sublease agreement related to a retail
space ends at the day on which the leased retail space has to be evicted
by the main lessee according to a judgment of the court as meant in Article
7:296, paragraph 5, rendered on a legal claim of the main lessor.
- 2. If the main lessee has not or not correctly
informed the sublessee about the lease period which applies or was accepted
under the main lease agreement or if he has not watched over the interests
of the sublessee sufficiently when the main lease agreement was ended
or when the date was set on which he has to evict the retail space, then
he is obliged to compensate the damage which the sublessee suffers as
a result
- 3. The main lessee against whom the main
lessor has filed a legal claim which affects the interests of the sublessee,
is entitled to call the sublessee to court.
Article 7:307 Subrogation (substitution) of the lessee
of a retail space
- 1. If the lessee wants to transfer his business,
which he or someone else conducts in the leased retail space, then he
may claim in court to become authorised to replace himself with a third
person who will continue his contractual position under the existing lease
agreement as lessee.
- 2. In considering such a legal claim of
the lessee, the court decides with due observance of all circumstances
of the case, on the understanding that the court may only award the legal
claim when the lessee or the other person who conducts the business in
the leased retail space has compelling reasons to transfer this business
and that the court has to reject the legal claim at all times if the proposed
new lessee does not offer sufficient guarantees for full compliance with
the lease agreement or for a proper conduct of business.
- 3. The court may in its judgement grant
its authorisation under certain conditions or impose one or more obligations
or duties on the old or new lessee.
Article 7:308 Compensation for goodwill and other
benefits at the end of the lease agreement
- 1. If the lessor, after the lease agreement
has ended by termination, enjoys a benefit as a result of the fact that
the leased retail space is used again to conduct a business similar to
that of the former lessee or sublessee to whom the retail space was rightfully
subleased, then this former lessee or sublessee may claim a compensation
from the lessor which is to be determined in fairness.
- 2. A benefit resulting from the nature or
position of the retail space or from changes introduced to it, does not
qualify for the purpose of paragraph 1.
- 3. The compensation cannot be granted when
the retail space only after one year since the end of the lease agreement
is used again to conduct a similar business.
Article 7:309 Demolition in the public interest and
compensation for damages
- 1. If a lessor, to whom the rights and obligations
from the lease agreement have passed by virtue of Article 7:226, has ended
this agreement on the basis of a termination made in connection with the
fact that the leased construction has to be demolished in view of the
completion of works to be implemented in the public interest, then he
has to pay damages to the lessee and the sublessee to whom the retail
space was rightfully subleased because of the loss of the possibility
that the lease agreement without this passage would have been continued.
- 2. The lessor also has to pay damages as
referred to in paragraph 1 if the passage has occurred after the previous
lessor had terminated the lease agreement in connection with the fact
that the leased construction after the passage will be demolished in view
of the completion of works to be implemented in the public interest. Where
the right of ownership of the leased retail space has been transferred
to a new owner at a moment on which the lease agreement already had been
ended by termination, the damages must be paid by the new owner who will
start the demolition.
- 3. The lease agreement is considered to
have been terminated in connection with the fact that the leased construction
will be demolished in view of the completion of works to be implemented
in the public interest, if demolition starts within six years after the
termination.
- 4. Work to realize a specific use in accordance
with a land use plan, intending to reconstruct a built-up area, is in
any event considered to be done in the public interest.
- 5. The present Article not only applies
to retail spaces in the sense of Article 7:290, but also to a constructed
immovable thing or a part thereof that is leased with the intention to
be used for another kind of business or enterprise than the ones mentioned
in Article 7:290.
Article 7:310 Rescission of a lease agreement in connection
with the realization of a land use plan
- 1. If a lessor, to whom the rights and obligations
from the lease agreement have passed by virtue of Article 7:226, wants
to realize a specific use of the leased property in accordance with a
valid land use plan, then the court may rescind the lease agreement as
of a specific date on a legal claim filed for this purpose by the lessor.
- 2. The lessee and the sublessee to whom
the retail space was rightfully subleased, may claim a compensation for
damages. In determining this compensation the possibility that the lease
agreement without that passage would have been continued, is taken into
account.
- 3. The present Article not only applies
to retail spaces in the sense of Article 7:290, but also to a constructed
immovable thing or a part thereof that is leased with the intention to
be used for another kind of business or enterprise than the ones mentioned
in Article 7:290.
|